In his revolutionary book, “Think Again,” organizational psychologist Adam Grant critically analyzes our thinking frameworks and highlights the urgent need for a shift in perspective. Grant organizes the book into four compelling sections, each focusing on a distinct aspect of rethinking.

Part 1: The Art of Individual Rethinking

Adam Grant explores the necessity of taking a moment to reassess our knowledge and thought patterns in our fast-paced lives. He advocates for a mindset that welcomes change, like a scientist’s natural curiosity and readiness to challenge the status quo.

Grant invites us to consider ourselves in various roles:

• The preacher, steadfast in their beliefs
• The prosecutor, keen on pointing out flaws
• The politician, adept at swaying opinions

He suggests that this metaphorical dance is all too familiar. Yet he poses the question: What if we adopted an alternate stance of thinking that favors inquiry over certainty and curiosity over fixed beliefs?

He delves into the idea that our level of intelligence doesn’t automatically grant us the flexibility to rethink or be open to new viewpoints. Our biases often overshadow our judgment, hindering our ability to see past our initial assumptions. According to Grant, the true opportunity for growth lies in our willingness to stay open to change, which enables us to reassess and evolve.

Grant emphasizes balancing knowing too little and believing we know everything. This balance is described as a place where humility and confidence meet, acknowledging our current knowledge while being aware of the vast unknown.

He highlights the importance of those who challenge our thinking, likening them to essential alarms that prompt us to rethink and refine our ideas. He argues that creating a supportive environment that encourages us to stay grounded and open to revisiting our beliefs is crucial.

Concluding, Grant emphasizes the importance of separating our identity from our beliefs, allowing for personal evolution. This process, reminiscent of Yoda’s wisdom, involves unlearning and relearning, symbolizing a journey of continuous growth and adaptation.

Part 2: Interpersonal Rethinking: The Art of Influencing Others

In the second part of his book, “Think Again,” Adam Grant delves into the intricate dynamics of opening others’ minds. He takes inspiration from the insightful words of Tim Kreider, stating, “Exhausting someone in an argument is not the same as convincing him.” This quote serves as a foundation for his exploration of the nuanced approaches that can facilitate meaningful changes in individuals’ perceptions and beliefs.

Grant underlines the power of acknowledging a strong argument from a differing perspective. This affirmation demonstrates that we aren’t merely adopting the uncompromising stances of preachers, prosecutors, or politicians. Instead, argumentation becomes a form of dance where respect for your partner’s steps is as important as your own.

He warns against the pitfalls of becoming a ‘logic bully,’ advocating for a demeanor imbued with tranquility and self-assuredness. Infusing a dose of uncertainty in our conversations can ignite curiosity, leading to richer discussions and enhanced understanding.

A central theme in this part is ‘counterfactual thinking.’ This psychological mechanism invites us to delve into ‘what if’ scenarios, speculating how different life experiences could have reshaped our current realities. For example, pondering how your perspectives and biases might have differed if you were born into a different racial or ethnic group. This cognitive exercise invites introspection into entrenched beliefs, highlighting their shaky foundations, and helps identify commonalities and shared interests. It ultimately fosters empathy, comprehension, and open-mindedness.

Motivational Interviewing

Another key concept Grant introduces in his “Think Again” book is motivational interviewing, a communication strategy for nudge individuals to reassess their viewpoints. Its essence lies in posing open-ended questions, engaging in reflective listening, and affirming the person’s ability and desire to change.

Grant brings this concept to life through a captivating narrative from healthcare. Marie-Helene, a mother staunchly against vaccination, is persuaded to reconsider her stance through the empathetic use of motivational interviewing by Dr. Arnaud Gagneur, known as the “vaccine whisperer.” This approach is not about dictating but about assisting people in breaking free from overconfidence cycles to see fresh possibilities.

Effective motivational interviewing follows a structured process:

1. Ask open-ended questions that facilitate thoughtful consideration.
2. Engage in reflective listening to understand the person’s perspective accurately.
3. Validate the person’s ability and willingness to change.
4. Summarize key points at critical junctures or the conversation’s end, reaffirming reasons for change, clarifying misconceptions, and discussing next steps.

The success of motivational interviewing hinges on asking genuinely curious questions that don’t carry hidden agendas of persuasion or correction. It requires resisting the ‘righting reflex,’ our instinctual desire to offer solutions and fix problems. This approach encourages a shift in focus, moving from being ‘right’ to nurturing the skill of understanding differing viewpoints and fostering productive dialogues around them.

Part 3: Collective Rethinking: Cultivating Learning Communities

We should embrace learning and how we think throughout our lives, not confine them to specific periods. Grant warns against joining ‘idea cults’ that uphold certain notions as absolute truths. Instead, he encourages us to explore new perspectives and maintain an ever-learning mindset.

In addition to the concepts introduced in Part 3, Grant emphasizes the importance of differentiating between skeptics and deniers. A denier, entrenched in their beliefs, dismisses new information and manipulates facts to suit their narrative. This rigid stance, embodying the preacher, prosecutor, or politician mode, prevents any form of rethinking.

On the contrary, skepticism is integral to the scientific method and, thus, to the skill of rethinking. Being a skeptic encourages us to continually seek new perspectives and engage in meaningful dialogues. The power of questioning propels us towards a mindset where the focus shifts from an obsession with being right to building the skills necessary to entertain diverse viewpoints and engage in constructive debates.

So, cultivating a skeptic’s approach, characterized by being ever-questioning, ever-curious, and ever-open to new possibilities, is vital. Such an approach forms the bedrock for creating communities of lifelong learners, always in pursuit of knowledge and growth.

Part 4: The Escape Route from Tunnel Vision

Grant ends his book with a critical reminder to evade the trap of escalation of commitment. This trap leads us to invest more heavily in a failing course of action rather than reevaluating it. The courage to change course, or ‘pivot,’ is as important as the perseverance to see a plan through.

He also calls for regular introspection and evaluation of our life goals to prevent them from becoming fossilized parts of our identities. Additionally, he cautions against the constant pursuit of happiness at the cost of present joy.

Grant’s students often refer to their careers in a three-stage progression of self-esteem:

• Acknowledging our lack of importance.
• Recognizing our importance.
• Ultimately seeking to contribute to something of significance.

The journey to this third phase can enhance our happiness, a sentiment echoed by philosopher John Stuart Mill, “Those are only happy who have their minds fixed on some object other than their own happiness…”.

In “Think Again,” Adam Grant provides us with the tools to approach our thought processes and engage in effective rethinking critically. As we shift our perspectives and challenge our beliefs, we become better equipped to navigate the complexities of our rapidly changing world.

Keep the Inspiration Flowing: More Must-Reads

For more inspirational books, check out my review of Becky Blades’s “Start More Than You Can Finish: A Creative Permission Slip to Unleash Your Best Idea. ”